Ultimate Guide to the Best Souvenir Shops on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island isn’t just a paradise of sugar-white sands and turquoise waters—it’s also a treasure trove for souvenir hunters. From charming beach boutiques to quirky gift shops, the island’s stores are filled with keepsakes that capture the laid-back coastal lifestyle.

Whether you’re searching for a hand-painted seashell, a breezy AMI-branded T-shirt, or elegant home décor with a seaside twist, there’s something for every taste and budget. Many shops showcase the work of local artisans, so your memento might be as unique as your island adventure.

Bring a piece of Anna Maria Island home with you, and let the memories of salty breezes and golden sunsets linger long after your trip ends.

Alvin’s Island

• 3602 East Bay Drive · Holmes Beach
• 305-471-9394 extension 753
• Open · Daily · 8:00 AM to 11:00 PM

Alvin’s Island souvenir shop is known for their vast selection of beach-themed keepsakes—think brightly colored T-shirts, keychains, mugs, and shot glasses emblazoned with local destination logos. The stores also carry practical beach essentials like towels, toys, and swimwear, making it convenient to pick up both gifts and vacation must-haves.

---

AMI Outfitters

• 401 Pine Avenue · Anna Maria
• 941-254-4996
• Open · Monday through Saturday · 10:00 AM to 4:30 PM

While not a traditional gift store, AMI Outfitters offers functional, high-quality souvenirs with a coastal twist, including branded hats, sun shirts, and gear perfect for island adventures. Their selection caters especially to outdoor enthusiasts, with items that blend utility and island style. It’s the ideal place to pick up a practical memento that captures the spirit of Anna Maria Island.

---

Anna Maria General Store

• 503 Pine Avenue · Anna Maria
• 941-779-9200
• Open · Monday through Saturday · 8:00 AM to 9:00 PM
• Open · Sunday · 8:00 AM to 7:00 PM

Anna Maria General Store blends the charm of a 1950s general store with a curated collection of locally made souvenirs—think embroidered caps, branded items, and island-themed keepsakes that capture the laid‑back essence of AMI. While the store is primarily known as a grocery and deli, its modest yet thoughtful souvenir selection offers practical and memorable finds worth a stop during your Pine Avenue stroll.

---

Artist Haven AMI

• 5351 Gulf Drive · Holmes Beach
• 941-242-5794
• Open · Tuesday through Saturday · 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM

Artist Haven AMI is a charming Holmes Beach boutique and creative studio showcasing an ever-changing array of handmade treasures—including paintings, jewelry, pottery, woodwork, and one-of-a-kind art on unconventional items like palm fronds and window screens—that beautifully reflect the coastal spirit of the island. This shop is more than a place to browse—it’s a warm, inviting space that uplifts both artists and visitors, infusing every handcrafted piece with a sense of community and creativity.

Back Alley Treasures

• 108 Bridge Street · Bradenton Beach
• 224-209-1480
• Open · Daily · 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Back Alley Treasures offers an eclectic mix of souvenirs crafted by local artists—think whimsical stained glass, handmade jewelry, quirky paintings, and repurposed art pieces—perfect for those looking for one-of-a-kind gifts. Unlike typical souvenir shops, it’s a café-bar-gallery hybrid where you can grab a coffee, spiked smoothie, or craft beer while browsing beach-themed treasures and island art, making it a memorable stop that combines shopping with laid-back local vibes.

---

Beach Blossom Studio

• 505 Pine Avenue · Anna Maria
• 941-451-7050
• Open · Daily · 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Beach Blossom Studio is a charming boutique offering vibrant, beach-inspired souvenirs—from unique jewelry and illustrated phone cases to tote bags, mugs, keychains, and journals adorned with tropical motifs. Items feature original artwork, making them truly special keepsakes rather than mass-produced trinkets. Whether you’re picking up a handmade necklace or a colorful beach towel, everything at Beach Blossom Studio captures the island’s serene and sunny vibes beautifully.

---

Bridge Street Bazaar

• 107 Bridge Street Unit A · Bradenton Beach
• 941-778-3400
• Open · Daily · 9:00 AM to 10:00 PM

Bridge Street Bazaar, nestled on historic Bridge Street, is bursting with vibrant souvenirs, beachwear, toys, sunglasses, hats, greeting cards, sand dollar accessories, and classic island T-shirts—everything you need for the perfect Gulf Coast memento. Whether you’re with kids or shopping solo, it’s a go‑to spot to grab island-themed clothing, trinkets, and practical beach gear in a fun and welcoming setting.

---

Cove

• 104 Bridge Street · Bradenton Beach
• 941-405-9227
• Open · Sunday through Wednesday · 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM VERIFY
• Open · Thursday through Saturday · 10:00 AM to 8:30 PM VERIFY

Cove offers a carefully curated collection of coastal-inspired gifts and art, including beautiful handcrafted jewelry, home décor, and local artwork that feel distinctly authentic to the island. Their high-quality, one-of-a-kind pieces—such as sea-glass creations, driftwood accents, and painted turtle dishes—make it much more than just a beachy souvenir shop. Cove is a peaceful, gallery-like space where the ambiance and personalized service enhance the experience of finding truly meaningful keepsakes

---

Ginny’s and Jane E’s Café and Coastal Store

• 9807 Gulf Drive · Anna Maria
• 941-778-3170
• Daily · 7:00 AM to 12:00 PM

At Ginny’s & Jane E’s, the gift shop complements the café with a quirky, retro‑inspired boutique packed with eclectic souvenirs like handmade coastal jewelry, quirky postcards, seashell art, and up-cycled crafts you won’t find elsewhere. Their custom T‑shirts, funky trinkets, and vintage‑style gifts beautifully reflect the island’s laid‑back and nostalgic vibe, making them standout keepsakes. Visiting here means you’ll get more than a souvenir—you’ll enjoy local flavor from their cafe and bakery, making it a unique combination of food and fun retail in a cheerful, island‑themed setting.

---

Green Turtle Shell and Gift Shop

• 701 Gulf Drive North · Bradenton Beach
• 941-778-2943
• Open · Daily · 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM

The Green Turtle Shell & Gift Shop—said to be the oldest gift shop on Anna Maria Island—showcases a wide array of beachy souvenirs like T-shirts, hoodies, shot glasses, magnets, and seashell keepsakes. Shelves brim with handcrafted jewelry, nautical décor, quirky gifts, and shells, making it a treasure trove of island charm and ideal for picking up a thoughtful Gulf Coast memento.

---

Island Bazaar

• 3304 East Bay Drive · Holmes Beach
• 941-778-3443
• Open · Daily · 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM

Island Bazaar is a vibrant souvenir destination offering everything from beachwear, swimsuits, and apparel to toys, jewelry, and gifts at reasonable prices. Whether you’re shopping solo or with family, the store is well-organized and stocked with a wide selection of beach essentials and island-themed trinkets that make ideal Gulf Coast mementos.

---

Island Trader

• 5336 Gulf Drive · Holmes Beach
• 941-778-5909
• Open · Daily · 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Island Trader offers a broad array of souvenirs—think island-themed T‑shirts, sweatshirts, jewelry, beach decor, and practical essentials—perfect for both trendy and casual shoppers. Whether you’re looking for colorful trinkets, seashell wall art, or comfortable island wear, Island Trader feels like a convenient, well-stocked stop for capturing the spirit of AMI.

---

Pineapple Marketplace

• 425 Pine Avenue · Anna Maria
• 941-216-4226
• Open · Monday through Saturday · 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM
• Open · Sunday · 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM

Pineapple Marketplace is a vibrant cooperative space featuring over 30 local vendors under one roof—expect to find a wide array of souvenirs such as island-themed apparel, jewelry, home décor, novelty gifts, and more eclectic treasures. It’s often described as a boutique flea‑market. Whether you’re hunting for a unique piece of art, collectible, or a high‑quality island T‑shirt, this is a go‑to stop for one‑of‑a‑kind keepsakes.

---

The Sand Dollar Gift Shop

• 5302 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
• 941-778-2024
• Open · Monday through Thursday · 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM
• Open · Sunday · 11:00 AM to 3:00 PM

Sand Dollar Gift Shop combines coastal charm with boutique flair—stocking beach-inspired clothing, jewelry, home decor, bath products, candles, and unique gifts. With its whimsical, shabby‑chic interior and thoughtfully curated displays, it feels more like a lifestyle gallery than a traditional tourist shop. Whether you’re browsing for stylish beachwear or artisanal home accents, Sand Dollar stands out for its uniquely local finds.

---

Shiny Fish Emporium

• 306 Pine Avenue · Anna Maria
• 941-896-9742
• Open · Monday through Friday · 10:00 AM to 5:30 PM
• Open · Saturday · 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM
• Open · Sunday · 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM

Shiny Fish Emporium is a vibrant family‑run boutique brimming with eclectic coastal gifts—from sparkling jewelry and whimsical accessories to tropical resort wear and hand‑painted sand dollars you can customize on-site. They pair playful, nostalgic décor reminiscent of 1950s Florida with a curated collection of global and local artists’ creations including unique home accents, and original t-shirts and baby gear. Known as a favorite destination for families and treasure hunters alike.

---

Sun and Surf Beach Shop

• 5418 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
• 941-778-6497
• Open · Monday through Saturday · 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM
• Open · Sunday · 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM

Sun & Surf Beach Shop, also affectionately known as “The Store With the Birds” offers a lively mix of high-quality souvenirs including tropical-themed T-shirts, hats, accessories, beach cover‑ups, and branded items emblazoned with the island’s charm. Visitors love browsing their selection of unique gifts, jewelry, and beach supplies while enjoying the friendly, fun atmosphere—complete with colorful parrots greeting guests outside. Whether you’re shopping for stylish beachwear, quirky keepsakes, or everyday souvenirs, Sun & Surf delivers island style with a memorable, family-owned flair.

---

Two Sides of Nature

• 101 North Bay Boulevard #1A · Anna Maria
• 941-779-2432
• Open · Daily · 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM

Nestled in Bayview Plaza, Two Sides of Nature offers a bright lineup of resort-style apparel, including high-quality AMI‑branded T‑shirts, sweatshirts, crewnecks, and tanks for all ages and genders. Alongside clothing, the shop features colorful coastal décor and gift items—like beach‑themed signs, candles, and beverage holders—making it more than just a souvenir stop, but a stylish boutique experience.

---

West Coast Surf Shop

• 3902 Gulf Drive · Homes Beach
• 941-778-1001
• Open · Monday through Saturday · 9:30 AM to 4:30 PM
• Open · Sunday · 10:00 AM to 4:30 PM

West Coast Surf Shop proudly holds the title of Florida’s oldest surf shop—established in 1964—and offers a vibrant collection of branded T‑shirts, board shorts, hats, sunglasses, sandals, and beach accessories that make memorable island souvenirs. The shop’s wide merchandise variety and nostalgic surf-shop vibe makes it a standout among Anna Maria Island souvenir stops.

---

The White Egret

• 10006 Gulf Drive · Anna Maria
• 941-778-3782
• Open · Monday through Friday · 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM
• Open · Sunday · 12:00 PM to 5:00 PM

The White Egret is a chic boutique offering a refined selection of coastal-inspired souvenirs and gifts—think elegant home accents, candles, linens, and décor pieces that blend style with seaside serenity. Their apparel and accessories are curated with care, stocking coastal-chic fashion, curated jewelry, and resort-ready essentials for both everyday wear and special island outings. The boutique’s upscale ambiance and personalized attention elevates souvenir shopping into a relaxed coastal-lifestyle experience.

---

Until next time…

· izzy