Updated: May 2026
Anna Maria Island may be known for fresh seafood, but it’s also home to some seriously good pizza. Whether you’re craving a classic slice after a long beach day, a wood-fired pie paired with wine, or a casual family dinner, the island delivers a surprising variety from no-frills neighborhood spots to elevated Italian dining experiences.
This guide covers the best pizza on Anna Maria Island and the surrounding areas of Bradenton Beach, and Longboat Key. Whatever you’re in the mood for, there’s a pie here with your name on it.
Danny’s Pizzeria
- 7220 Manatee Avenue West · Bradenton
- 941-795-1111
- Tuesday – Thursday · 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM
- Friday & Saturday · 11:00 AM to 9:30PM
Just a short drive over the Cortez Bridge, Danny’s Pizzeria is the real deal for New York-style pizza. This family-run spot goes well beyond pizza, with chicken parmigiana, sausage and peppers, hero sandwiches, salads, and pasta rounding out a menu that feels like a proper Italian-American dinner. Pizza by the slice is available, and online ordering is open for delivery with a $10 minimum. Call for carryout.
Domino’s Pizza
- 5606 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
- 941-778-6641
Sometimes after a full day in the sun, familiar is exactly what you want. The Holmes Beach Domino’s delivers quickly with a wide range of options, making it a solid choice for a low-key night in. Order online or call for delivery or carryout.
Double Deez Chicago Style Hot Dogs
- 3009 Gulf Drive · Holmes Beach
- 941-251-5595
- Wednesday – Saturday · 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM
- Sunday · 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM
Don’t let the name fool you. Double Deez serves up serious tavern-style pizza with a crispy thin crust and bold flavor, cut into small squares in classic party-cut style. It’s a no-frills spot with a great personality, and the pizza delivers every time. Order through Island Eats Delivery or call for carryout.
La Norma Italian Restaurant
- 5370 Gulf of Mexico Drive #104 · Longboat Key
- 941-383-6262
- Daily · 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM
La Norma brings authentic Italian technique to the table with pizzas that balance a crisp exterior, airy interior, rich tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella. The warm atmosphere makes it work equally well for a casual dinner or a special occasion. Order online for carryout.
Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant
- 201 Gulf Drive · Bradenton Beach
- 941-778-0771
Oma’s is the answer to a late-night pizza craving. Their Sicilian Oma Special is loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives, and the dessert menu with tiramisu and chocolate-dipped cannoli is worth saving room for. Call for delivery or carryout.
Pizza Social
- 308 Pine Avenue · Anna Maria
- 941-251-4070
- Wednesday – Monday · 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Pizza Social is one of the most beloved spots on the island, and for good reason. Handmade dough, house tomato sauce, and a 700-degree imported Italian pizza oven produce a crust that’s hard to argue with. Choose from 11 signature pizzas or build your own, and round it out with a fresh salad or garlic Parmesan dough nuggets. A cauliflower crust option is available for gluten-free diners, and a rotating selection of Florida craft beer keeps things interesting. Delivery runs through Island Eats. Order online or call for carryout.
Pizzano’s Pizza and Grinderz
- 5318 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
- 941-778-3663
- Monday – Thursday · 10:00 AM to midnight
- Friday & Saturday · 10:00 AM to 1:00 AM
- Sunday · 11:00 AM to midnight
Pizzano’s is the late-night anchor of the Anna Maria Island pizza scene. With 18 specialty pizzas available in both classic round and Sicilian square styles, plus wings, subs, pasta, and salads, there’s something for everyone. Their wings are worth a separate mention and for the full story, see my Ultimate Guide to Chicken Wings on Anna Maria Island. Order online for delivery or call for carryout.
Slim’s Place
- 9701 Gulf Drive · Anna Maria
- 941-567-4056
- Monday 3:00 PM to 10:00 PM
- Tuesday – Sunday · 11:30 AM to 10:00 PM
Slim’s brings a Philly sports bar energy to the north end of the island, and their thin-crust pizza holds its own alongside the legendary cheesesteak sandwiches. Eleven specialty pizzas plus a classic cheese option, and happy hour from 3 to 5 PM on weekdays makes it an easy stop. Carryout only, no delivery.
Ventura’s Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar
- 6814 Gulf of Mexico Drive · Longboat Key
- 941-312-4975
- Daily · 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM
Ventura’s is the elevated option on this list. House-made sauce, fresh mozzarella, a thoughtfully curated wine list, and an intimate atmosphere make it the right call for a date night or a slower, more indulgent evening. Their pizzas are straightforward and well-executed, which is exactly the point. Order online for pickup.
Vinny’s Italian Kitchen
- AMI. Plaza, 5337 Gulf Dr Suite 500 · Holmes Beach
- 941-896-9754
- Monday – Saturday · 11 AM to 7 PM
Vinny’s is a genuine Italian experience, from the thin-crust traditional pizzas to the on-site market and Italian deli. A gluten-free option is available. Carryout only, no delivery.
Final Bite
Anna Maria Island punches well above its weight when it comes to pizza. From a late-night Sicilian square at Pizzano’s to a candlelit pie at Ventura’s, the options are genuinely good and worth exploring beyond your first instinct. Pair dinner with a look at my Anna Maria Island Restaurant Guide and Ultimate Guide to Italian Restaurants on Anna Maria Island for everything else the island has to offer.
Until next time…
· izzy