Updated: June 2026

If you are visiting Anna Maria Island, stopping for ice cream is practically part of the experience. After a day at the beach, there is nothing better than cooling off with a cone in hand while wandering the island’s charming streets.

From classic scoop shops to small-batch creameries and gelato spots, this guide covers the best ice cream on Anna Maria Island, perfect for a quick treat, post-dinner stop, or must-visit dessert during your trip.

Quick Picks: Best Ice Cream on Anna Maria Island

• Best classic scoop shop: Two Scoops
• Best Pine Avenue stop: Dips Ice Cream
• Best variety: Small Town Creamery
• Best for something lighter: Frozen Yogurt & Acai
• Best gelato: Gelato·Go

---

Two Scoops

• 101 South Bay Boulevard · Anna Maria
• 941-779-2422
• 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM

Two Scoops is one of the most well-known ice cream stops on Anna Maria Island, located just steps from the waterfront near the City Pier. It is a go-to spot after the beach, especially in the evening when people wander in for a classic cone. With over 30 flavors ranging from Key Lime Pie and Sea Salt Caramel to Toasted Coconut and Blueberry Pie, there is something for everyone, including sugar-free and dairy-free options. Popular picks include homemade waffle cones, classic sundaes, milkshakes and malts, and old-fashioned root beer. Grab your cone and walk across to the pier for sunset. It is one of the easiest ways to experience the island, and one of those simple moments you will not forget. For more ideas like this, see my Ultimate Guide to Free Things to Do on Anna Maria Island.

---

Dips Ice Cream

• 503 Pine Avenue · Anna Maria
• 941-778-1706
• 10:00 AM to 11:00 PM

Dips Ice Cream is a longtime favorite located inside the Anna Maria General Store, and honestly, the two go hand in hand. Known for its locally made ice cream, the shop offers a fun mix of classic and creative flavors like Oreo, Peanut Butter Bar, and the very aptly named “Exhausted Parent.” Soft serve and dairy-free options are also available, along with milkshakes and nostalgic candy treats. While you are there, take some time to explore the General Store itself. For everything it has to offer, see my Island Living Made Easy with Anna Maria General Store. Then grab a cone and walk Pine Avenue. It is one of the most charming stretches on the island and the kind of afternoon that does not need a plan.

---

Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery

• 9807 Gulf Drive · Anna Maria
• 941-896-3172
• Sunday – Thursday · 8:00 AM to 9:00 PM
• Friday & Saturday · 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM

Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery is one of those rare spots that works at any hour. Start your morning with coffee and fresh baked pastries or circle back in the evening for a scoop of one of their rotating homemade flavors. The combination of ice cream and a full bakery case makes it easy to linger, and the extended weekend hours mean there is almost always a reason to stop in. For more great bakery finds on the island, see my Ultimate Guide to Bakeries on Anna Maria Island. A great anchor for a slow morning or a sweet way to end the night.

---

Anna Maria Island Frozen Yogurt & Acai

• 5604 B Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
• 941-842-5555
• Monday–Thursday · 1:00 PM to 9:00 PM
• Friday & Saturday · 2:00 PM to 10:00 PM
• Sunday · 2:00 PM to 9:00 PM

Anna Maria Island Frozen Yogurt and Acai is the spot for when you want something cool and refreshing without the weight of a full scoop. This build-your-own dessert stop in Holmes Beach lets you customize frozen yogurt with your choice of toppings or opt for an acai bowl instead. It is a great grab-and-go option after the beach, especially when the heat of the day has you craving something light and simple.

---

Small Town Creamery

• 5404 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
• 941-213-9107
• Daily · 11:30 AM to 9:30 PM

Small Town Creamery sits in a plaza at Marina and Gulf Drive and delivers big when it comes to options. With over 50 rotating flavors, shakes, floats, homemade fudge, and specialty candies, it is the kind of place where everyone in the group finds something they love. Grab your treat and take a slow wander through the plaza, and keep your eyes open while you are there. It is the same spot featured in my The Colorful Parrots Outside Sun & Surf on Anna Maria Island, and the birds are very much part of the experience.

---

Holy Cow Ice Cream

• 3234 East Bay Drive · Holmes Beach
• 941-779-0690
• Monday–Saturday · 1:00 PM to 8:30 PM
• Sunday · 2:00 PM to 8:30 PM

Holy Cow Ice Cream is a solid Holmes Beach stop with 36 plus flavors, indoor seating, and a menu that covers all the classics alongside some more creative options. Dairy-free and sugar-free choices are available as well. It sits conveniently near the bridge, making it an easy detour on your way on or off the island when you need a quick dessert break to cap off the day.

---

Baskin Robbins

• 3302 East Bay Drive · Holmes Beach
• 941-242-0260
• 6:00 AM to 8:00 PM

Baskin Robbins is exactly what you expect it to be, and sometimes that is exactly what you need. A familiar name, a rotating lineup of classic flavors, and ice cream cakes for special occasions. It is a convenient option when you are nearby and in the mood for something straightforward and satisfying.

---

Gelato·Go

• 119 Bridge Street Unit 150 · Bradenton Beach
• 941-782-8414
• 1:00 PM to 10:00 PM

Gelato Go is tucked right into Bridge Street, one of the most walkable and enjoyable stretches on the island. Italian-style gelato, rotating flavors, and fruit-based sorbets make it a naturally lighter way to finish a meal or a sunset walk. Pistachio, Stracciatella, Chocolate, and seasonal fruit sorbets are among the favorites. It pairs perfectly with everything else Bridge Street has to offer. For more on what is nearby, see my Ultimate Guide to Bridge Street on Anna Maria Island.

---

Last Bite

Whether you are craving a classic scoop, small-batch flavors, or a refreshing gelato, there is no shortage of great spots to enjoy ice cream on Anna Maria Island. From Pine Avenue strolls to sunset stops near the water, each shop offers its own take on the perfect island treat.

For more local favorites, visit my Anna Maria Island Restaurant Guide.

Sometimes the best island plans are the simplest. Just follow the sunshine, grab a cone, and see where the day takes you.

Until next time…

· izzy