Updated: April 2026

If you’re visiting Anna Maria Island, stopping for ice cream is practically part of the experience. After a day at the beach, there’s nothing better than cooling off with a cone in hand while wandering the island’s charming streets.

From classic scoop shops to small-batch creameries and gelato spots, this guide covers the best ice cream on Anna Maria Island—perfect for a quick treat, post-dinner stop, or must-visit dessert during your trip.

Quick Picks: Best Ice Cream on Anna Maria Island

• Best classic scoop shop: Two Scoops
• Best Pine Avenue stop: Dips Ice Cream
• Best variety: Small Town Creamery
• Best for something lighter: Frozen Yogurt & Acai
• Best gelato: Gelato·Go

---

Two Scoops

• 📍 101 South Bay Boulevard · Anna Maria
• 📞 941-779-2422
• 🕒 Daily · 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Two Scoops is one of the most well-known ice cream stops on Anna Maria Island, located just steps from the waterfront near the City Pier. It’s a go-to spot after the beach, especially in the evening when people wander in for a classic cone.

With over 30 flavors, the shop offers everything from Key Lime Pie and Sea Salt Caramel to Toasted Coconut and Blueberry Pie. Sugar-free and dairy-free options are also available.

Popular picks include:

• Homemade waffle cones
• Classic sundaes
• Milkshakes and malts
• Old-fashioned root beer

Good to know

• Located near the City Pier
• Serves cones, cups, pints, and quarts
• Open daily into the evening

Local tip
Grab your cone and walk across to the pier for sunset—it’s one of the easiest ways to experience the island. You can also find more ideas in my Free Things to Do on Anna Maria Island.

---

Dips Ice Cream

📍 503 Pine Avenue · Anna Maria
📞 941-778-1706
🕒 Daily · 10:00 AM – 11:00 PM

Dips Ice Cream is a longtime favorite located inside the Anna Maria General Store. It’s a popular stop while exploring the north end, especially for a quick treat during a stroll through the shops.

Known for its locally made ice cream, the shop offers a mix of classic and creative flavors like Oreo, Peanut Butter Bar, and the unique “Exhausted Parent.” Soft serve and dairy-free options are also available.

Popular picks include:

• Hand-dipped ice cream
• Soft serve options
• Milkshakes
• Candy and nostalgic treats

Good to know

• Located on Pine Avenue
• Inside Anna Maria General Store
• Open daily into the evening

Local tip
Grab a cone and walk Pine Avenue—it’s one of the most charming areas on the island for a relaxed afternoon.

---

Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery

📍 9807 Gulf Drive · Anna Maria
📞 941-896-3172
🕒 Sunday – Thursday · 8:00 AM – 9:00 PM / Friday & Saturday · 8:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery is a popular stop offering both homemade ice cream and fresh baked goods. It’s an easy choice whether you’re starting your day with coffee and pastries or stopping in for dessert later on.

The shop features rotating ice cream flavors along with baked items, making it a versatile option for everything from a quick breakfast to an evening treat.

Popular picks include:

• Hand-scooped ice cream
• Fresh baked pastries
• Ice cream cones and cups
• Seasonal desserts

Good to know

• Located on Pine Avenue
• Serves both ice cream and baked goods
• Open daily with extended weekend hours

Local tip
A great stop while exploring Pine Avenue—easy to pop in for coffee, dessert, or both.

---

Anna Maria Island Frozen Yogurt & Acai

📍 5604 B Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
📞 941-842-5555
🕒 Monday–Thursday · 1:00 PM – 9:00 PM
🕒 Friday & Saturday · 2:00 PM – 10:00 PM
🕒 Sunday · 2:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Anna Maria Island Frozen Yogurt & Acai is a build-your-own dessert spot in Holmes Beach, offering frozen yogurt and acai bowls as a lighter alternative to traditional ice cream.

Guests can customize their treats with a variety of toppings or choose a refreshing acai bowl, making it a simple grab-and-go option after the beach.

Popular picks include:

• Frozen yogurt with toppings
• Acai bowls
• Rotating flavors
• Light dessert options

Good to know

• Located in Holmes Beach
• Build-your-own style
• Open daily with varying hours

Local tip
A great option when you want something refreshing without the heaviness of traditional ice cream.

---

Small Town Creamery

📍 5404 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
📞 941-213-9107
🕒 Daily · 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM

Small Town Creamery is located in a plaza at Marina and Gulf Drive and is known for its wide selection of ice cream flavors. It’s a lively stop with plenty of options for both classic and creative tastes.

With over 50 flavors, the shop offers everything from traditional favorites to unique combinations, along with shakes, floats, and sweet treats.

Popular picks include:

• Rotating ice cream flavors
• Shakes and floats
• Homemade fudge
• Specialty candies

Good to know

• Located in a Holmes Beach plaza
• Offers 50+ flavors
• Open daily

Local tip
Grab your treat and take a stroll through the plaza—and don’t miss the birds! It’s the same spot featured in my Chirp Happens: Meet the Birds at the Sun and Surf Beach Shop on Anna Maria Island, so keep an eye out while you wander.

---

Holy Cow Ice Cream

📍 3234 East Bay Drive · Holmes Beach
📞 941-779-0690
🕒 Monday–Saturday · 1:00 PM – 8:30 PM
🕒 Sunday · 2:00 PM – 8:30 PM

Holy Cow Ice Cream is a Holmes Beach shop offering a wide range of ice cream flavors along with shakes, sundaes, and frozen treats. It’s a convenient stop for a classic dessert after a day on the island.

The shop features 36+ flavors including both traditional options and more unique selections, along with dairy-free and sugar-free choices.

Popular picks include:

• Sea Salt Caramel
• Double Fudge Brownie
• Blueberry Pie
• Milkshakes

Good to know

• Located on East Bay Drive
• Indoor seating available
• Open daily

Local tip
A convenient stop when heading on or off the island for a quick dessert break.

---

Baskin Robbins

📍 3302 East Bay Drive · Holmes Beach
📞 941-242-0260
🕒 Daily · 6:00 AM – 8:00 PM

Baskin-Robbins is a well-known ice cream shop offering a wide selection of flavors, originally known for its “31 flavors” concept. It’s a familiar stop for classic ice cream and quick desserts.

The shop offers a rotating variety of flavors along with ice cream cakes and sundaes for everyday treats or special occasions.

Popular picks include:

• Vanilla
• Chocolate
• Mint Chocolate Chip
• Cookies & Cream

Good to know

• National ice cream chain
• Offers ice cream cakes
• Open daily

Local tip
A quick and easy option for classic flavors when you’re nearby.

---

Gelato·Go

📍 119 Bridge Street · Unit 150 · Bradenton Beach
📞 941-782-8414
🕒 Daily · 1:00 PM – 10:00 PM

Gelato·Go is located on Bridge Street, offering Italian-style gelato in one of the most walkable areas on the island. It’s a popular stop after dinner or while exploring nearby shops.

The shop serves rotating gelato flavors and fruit-based sorbets, making it a refreshing option for a lighter dessert.

Popular picks include:

• Pistachio
• Stracciatella
• Chocolate
• Fruit sorbets

Good to know

• Located on Bridge Street
• Easy walk-up stop
• Open daily into the evening

Local tip
A great stop after dinner or a sunset walk. See more nearby spots in my Ultimate Guide to Bridge Street on Anna Maria Island.

---

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re craving a classic scoop, small-batch flavors, or a refreshing gelato, there’s no shortage of great spots to enjoy ice cream on Anna Maria Island. From Pine Avenue strolls to sunset stops near the water, each shop offers its own take on the perfect island treat.

If you’re planning your time on the island, you can pair your dessert stops with more local favorites in my Anna Maria Island Restaurant Guide.

Sometimes the best island plans are the simplest—just follow the sunshine, grab a cone, and see where the day takes you.

---

Until next time…

· izzy