Anna Maria Island may be known for fresh seafood, but it’s also home to some excellent pizza. Whether you’re craving a classic slice after a day at the beach, a wood-fired pie paired with wine, or a casual family-friendly dinner, the island offers a surprising variety of great pizza spots. From cozy local favorites to more elevated dining experiences, there’s something to satisfy every pizza lover.
This guide highlights the best places to get pizza on Anna Maria Island and nearby Cortez and Longboat Key. Whether you’re looking for traditional Italian flavors, creative toppings, or simply a convenient and delicious meal, these restaurants serve some of the best pizza on and around Anna Maria Island.
Contents
Danny’s Pizzeria
- 7220 Manatee Avenue West · Bradenton
- 941-795-1111
- Tuesday through Thursday · 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM
- Friday and Saturday · 11:00 AM to 9:30PM
Just a short drive over the Cortez Bridge to Bradenton, Danny’s Pizzeria offers an authentic New York-style pizza. This family-run restaurant also offers dinner-style meals like chicken parmigiana, sausage and peppers, hero sandwiches, salads, pasta, and pizza by the slice.
Order online for delivery with a $10 minimum purchase. Call for carryout service.
Domino’s Pizza
- 5606 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
- 941-778-6641
Sometimes, after a long day of beach fun, you just want a familiar meal. Domino’s Pizza offers fast delivery and a wide range of pizza options, making it a convenient choice for a cozy night in. It’s a reliable option when you’re craving pizza comfort without the need to venture out.
Order online or call in for delivery or carryout.
Double Deez Chicago Style Hot Dogs
- 3009 Gulf Drive · Holmes Beach
- 941-251-5595
- Wednesday through Saturday · 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM
- Sunday · 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM
Don’t let the name fool you—Double Deez on Anna Maria Island serves up serious tavern-style pizza that’s all about crispy, thin crust and bold flavor. Their pies are cut into small square pieces—often called a “party cut” or “Chicago-style thin crust” (not to be confused with deep dish). It’s a no-frills spot with a funny name, but the pizza is anything but a joke.
For delivery order through Island Eats Delivery or call or carryout.
La Norma Italian Restaurant
- 5370 Gulf of Mexico Drive #104 · Longboat Key
- 941-383-6262
- Daily · 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM
La Norma Italian Restaurant brings authentic Italian flavors to Anna Maria Island, with pizzas that highlight traditional techniques and high-quality ingredients. Each pizza features a perfectly balanced crust—crisp on the outside, soft and airy inside—topped with rich tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and thoughtfully selected toppings that reflect classic Italian recipes.
The warm, inviting atmosphere makes La Norma an excellent choice for both relaxed dinners and special occasions. Whether you prefer a simple Margherita or a more indulgent combination, the attention to detail and authenticity shine through in every bite.
Order online for carryout.
Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant
currently closed due to hurricanes
- 201 Gulf Drive · Bradenton Beach
- 941-778-0771
Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant offers both pizza and Italian dishes. Their Sicilian Oma Special is loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives. The restaurant also offers delicious calzones and tempting desserts like tiramisu and chocolate-dipped cannoli. With its late hours and delivery service, Oma’s is perfect for a late-night pizza craving or a cozy night in.
Call for delivery or carryout.
Pizza Social
- 308 Pine Avenue · Anna Maria
- 941-251-4070
- Wednesday through Monday · 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Pizza Social is renowned for its hand-crafted pizzas and fresh salads. The secret lies in their handmade dough and tomato-based pizza sauce. The 700-degree imported Italian pizza oven ensures a perfectly baked pie every time. Pizza Social offers 11 signature pizzas or build your own pizza, five salads or build your own salad, garlic Parmesan dough nuggets, and a rotating selection of Florida local craft beer. They also cater to gluten-free diets with a cauliflower crust option.
Order online for dellivery and pick up. Pizza Social uses a 3rd-party delivery service called Island Eats. By clicking the DELIVERY option, you will be redirected to the Island Eats website. If you have questions about your delivery order you must refer to the 6-digit confirmation number given to you by Island Eats when calling into the restaurant.
Order online for delivery. Call for carryout service.
Pizzano’s Pizza and Grinderz
- 5318 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
- 941-778-3663
- Monday through Thursday · 10:00 AM to midnight
- Friday and Saturday · 10:00 AM to 1:00 AM
- Sunday · 11:00 AM to midnight
Pizzano’s Pizza is known for its robust flavors and family-friendly atmosphere. Their menu features both classic round and Sicilian square pizzas. They offer 18 specialty pizzas, wings, salads, toasted subs, pasta, garlic bread, side orders, and dessert.
Their wings are also worth noting—learn more in my Ultimate Guide to Chicken Wings on Anna Maria Island. Pizzano’s is open late, so it’s perfect for a late dinner or an after-hours pizza craving.
Order online for delivery. Call for carryout service.
Slim’s Place
- 9701 Gulf Drive · Anna Maria
- 941-567-4056
- Monday 3:00 to 10:00 PM
- Tuesday through Sunday · 11:30 AM to 10:00 PM
Slim’s Place combines a fantastic sports atmosphere with Philly food and pizza. Known for its Philly cheesesteak sandwiches, this spot also serves up thin-crust pizzas. They offer a traditional cheese pizza and 11 specialty pizzas. Slim’s offers happy hour from 3 to 5 PM during the week.
Delivery not offered. Call for carryout service.
Ventura’s Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar
- 6814 Gulf of Mexico Drive · Longboat Key
- 941-312-4975
- Daily · 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM
Ventura’s Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar offers a refined yet welcoming setting to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine on Anna Maria Island. Their pizzas are crafted with care, featuring a crisp, flavorful crust topped with house-made sauce, fresh mozzarella, and high-quality ingredients that highlight traditional Italian flavors.
The restaurant’s intimate atmosphere and thoughtfully curated wine selection elevate the experience, making it an excellent choice for a relaxed dinner or special evening out. Whether paired with a glass of wine or enjoyed on its own, Ventura’s pizza delivers a satisfying balance of simplicity and sophistication, reflecting the restaurant’s commitment to quality and authenticity.
Order online for pickup.
Vinny’s Italian Kitchen
- AMI. Plaza, 5337 Gulf Dr Suite 500 · Holmes Beach
- 941-896-9754
- Monday through Saturday · 11 AM to 7 PM
Visit Vinny’s Italian Kitchen for an authentic Italian experience. This restaurant serves thin-crust pizzas in traditional Italian style and the chef provides a gluten free option. Be sure to explore their on-site market and Italian deli for a true taste of Italy.
Delivery not offered. Call for carryout service.
Conclusion
Anna Maria Island offers a surprisingly diverse pizza scene, with everything from casual slice shops to authentic Italian kitchens and elevated dining experiences. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite after the beach or settling in for a relaxed dinner, you’ll find plenty of great options to satisfy your pizza cravings.
For even more dining inspiration, explore my Ultimate Guide to Anna Maria Island Restaurants and Ultimate Guide to Italian Restaurants on Anna Maria Island to discover more of the island’s best places to eat.
Until next time…
· izzy
Breakfast is the most important meal of the day and finding the perfect restaurant can make a significant difference in starting your day off right. Anna Maria Island is home to many delicious breakfast restaurants with each spot offering a unique style and flavor.
Below is a list of restaurants for breakfasts on Anna Maria Island.
Nothing beats cold ice cream on a hot Florida day. This may be the reason there are quite a few ice cream shops located throughout Anna Maria Island (AMI).
This post is the ultimate guide to ice cream shops on AMI. If you are an ice cream aficionado, then this list is for you!
