Updated: June 2026
Anna Maria Island is known for pristine beaches and stunning sunsets, but the sushi scene here is worth talking about too. Whether you are craving classic nigiri, inventive specialty rolls, or a steaming bowl of ramen on the side, the island has options that deliver on both freshness and creativity. One spot even pairs the experience with waterfront views that make the meal itself feel like part of the island.
For everything else worth eating on the island, my Dining on Anna Maria Island: My Insider Guide is your complete resource.
Island Ocean Star
- 902 South Bay Boulevard · Anna Maria
- 941-251-6940
- Tuesday 0 Sunday · 4:00 PM to 9:30 PM
Island Ocean Star is the island’s only hibachi grill, and it delivers one of the most memorable dining experiences on Anna Maria Island. Nestled along the edge of Bimini Bay, the restaurant combines an interactive hibachi experience with an extensive Japanese menu that includes artfully prepared sushi, sashimi, tempura, teriyaki, and noodle dishes, all made with fresh ingredients and traditional technique.
Whether you are dining indoors in the cozy, elegant interior or out on the deck with bay views, the atmosphere is relaxed and upscale at the same time. A great choice for date nights, family dinners, or group celebrations. For more waterfront dining options, see my Ultimate Guide to Waterfront Dining on Anna Maria Island.
Fifty Three Fifty The Pourhouse
- 5350 Gulf Drive · Holmes Beach
- 941-251-3681
- Daily · 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM
Every Friday starting at 5 PM, Fifty Three Fifty The Pourhouse hosts Sushi Night, and it has become one of the more beloved weekly traditions on the island. Artfully crafted rolls, sashimi, and rotating creative specials pair perfectly with the cafe’s selection of craft beer, wine, and sake. The atmosphere is casual and vibrant, exactly the kind of place where a Friday night sushi dinner turns into a longer evening than you planned. For more on this spot, see its dedicated guide on the blog.
Sushi Ramen
- 9801 Gulf Drive #7 · Anna Maria Island
- 941-900-2537
- Daily · 1:00 PM to 11:00 PM
Sushi Ramen is known for freshness and presentation, with each roll crafted as much for visual appeal as for flavor. Standout menu items include the dragon balls and the spicy tuna hand rolls, which deliver just the right amount of heat. Whether you are stopping in for a quick bite or settling in for multiple courses, it is a satisfying and comfortably casual experience that holds its own against any sushi spot on the Gulf Coast.
Coastal Close
Great sushi on a barrier island is not something everyone expects, but Anna Maria Island delivers. Whether you are celebrating a special night out at Island Ocean Star, catching Sushi Night at The Pour House, or settling in for a casual dinner at Sushi Ramen, the island’s sushi scene is a genuine highlight worth planning around.
— izzy