If you don’t enjoy fishing, let the local fishermen handle the hard work for you. Anna Maria Island is home to several excellent seafood markets offering the freshest local catch. From wild Gulf shrimp to snapper, grouper, and stone crab, there’s something for every seafood lover. Check out the top picks for seafood markets that deliver quality, flavor, and a true taste of the island.
Captain Anthony’s
- 107 Spring Avenue · Anna Maria
- 941-807-0071
- Thursday through Monday · 12 to 5 PM
- Wednesday · closed
Captain Anthony’s on Anna Maria Island is a local gem run by Captain Anthony and his wife, Joanne. Known for its warm hospitality, the shack serves up fresh seafood favorites like Stone Crab, Red Snapper, Gulf Grouper, and house-made crab and fish dips. Guests can enjoy light bites like ceviche while their freshly caught fish is prepped for dinner. For those seeking adventure, Captain Anthony also offers fishing charters to reel in your own catch.
Cortez Bait & Seafood
- 12110 Cortez Road · Cortez
- 941-794-1547
- Monday through Saturday · 10 AM to 6 PM
- Sunday · 11 AM to % PM
Cortez Bait and Seafood lives by the motto: “We catch the fish, you eat the fish!” Located in the historic fishing village of Cortez, they offer a wide selection of freshly caught local fish along with everything you need to prepare it. From handcrafted sauces and spices to gourmet seasonings and condiments, their curated selection is the perfect complement to your catch. It’s a one-stop shop for fresh seafood and flavorful fixings straight from Florida’s Gulf waters.
Island Fresh Market AMI
- 5604 Marina Drive Suite A · Holmes Beach
- 941-567-6130
- Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday · 9 AM to 4 PM
- Saturday and Sunday · 9 AM to 1 PM
Island Fresh Market is your go-to spot for locally sourced goods, featuring fresh-caught seafood, seasonal produce, and regional specialties. They serve up ready-to-eat favorites like steamed shrimp, crab legs, and a classic Low Country boil. Inside, you’ll also find a wide selection of spices, sauces, dips, soups, and even key lime pie—everything you need to create a complete and delicious meal. Whether you’re planning lunch or dinner, Island Fresh Market makes it easy to shop local and eat well.
Star Fish Company
- 12306 46th Avenue West · Cortez
- 941-794-1243
- Monday · 10 AM to 3 PM
- Tuesday through Saturday · 10 AM to 6 PM
- Sunday · 11;30 AM to 3 PM
Just across the bridge in Cortez, The Starfish Company is a favorite for its combination fish market and dockside restaurant. Serving up fresh, locally caught seafood straight from the boat, it’s the perfect place to grab the day’s catch or enjoy a delicious waterfront meal. Whether you want your fish whole, expertly filleted, or cooked and served right there, they’ve got you covered. From fresh filets to flavorful seasonings and sides, The Starfish Company has everything you need for the ultimate seafood experience.
Until next time…
· izzy
When planning your visit, understanding Anna Maria Island’s weather becomes essential for making the most of your beach getaway. While the island welcomes visitors year-round, each season brings its own unique charm—from warm, breezy springs and sun-soaked summers to mild autumns and pleasantly cool winters.
Here’s a complete guide to Anna Maria Island’s climate to help you choose the perfect time to visit.
“Who has the best pizza?” It’s a question I hear over and over again from locals and visitors. Anna Maria Island is known for its spectacular beaches and tranquil waters but it also offers great pizza.
Below is the ultimate guide to pizza places on Anna Maria Island. Pizza lovers are in for a treat when visiting this beautiful slice of paradise.
Several restaurants on Anna Maria Island accept reservations offering a convenient way to enjoy the island’s vibrant dining scene.
Below are Anna Maria Island restaurants that accept reservations so you can enjoy your meal with minimal or no wait!
Key lime pie was officially declared Florida’s state pie in 2006.
While the Florida Keys are most commonly associated with Key lime pie, the entire state of Florida crushes on the dessert.
Here are the places on and near Anna Maria Island to grab a slice.
Breakfast is the most important meal of the day and finding the perfect restaurant can make a significant difference in starting your day off right. Anna Maria Island is home to many delicious breakfast restaurants with each spot offering a unique style and flavor.
Below is a list of restaurants for breakfasts on Anna Maria Island.