Updated: April 2026
This website uses affiliate links which may earn a commission for purchases at no additional cost to you.
Key lime pie on Anna Maria Island isn’t optional—it’s part of the rhythm of a beach day.
Born in the Florida Keys, where early cooks combined sweetened condensed milk, egg yolks, and tart native key limes into a simple no-bake custard, it has since become one of Florida’s most iconic desserts.
On Anna Maria Island, it fits seamlessly into the shoreline routine. After long afternoons in the sun, salt still on your skin and sand still in your shoes, there’s a moment when something cold, creamy, and citrus-bright just feels right. That’s where key lime pie comes in.
Not every slice is the same—and that’s the point. Some are classic and custardy, some are airy and sweet, some are best enjoyed with your feet in the sand and a sunset in front of you.
So instead of chasing one “perfect” slice, think of this as a guide to the best ways to experience key lime pie on and around Anna Maria Island.
Best Key Lime Pies on Anna Maria Island
If you only have a few days on the island, these are the key lime stops that consistently stand out for flavor, atmosphere, and that classic Florida experience.
Best Overall Key Lime Pie · The Waterfront Restaurant
Consistently one of the most talked-about slices on the island—smooth, balanced, and served in a setting that feels like the full AMI experience. Come for dinner, stay for sunset, and don’t skip dessert here.
Best Waterfront Key Lime Pie · Beach House Waterfront Restaurant
This is the “toes in the sand” version of key lime pie. It’s less about perfection and more about the moment—waves nearby, sunset in front of you, and a chilled slice that fits the setting perfectly.
Best Old Florida Fish House Experience ·Star Fish Company
No frills, no overthinking—just dockside seafood in a working fishing village. It’s the kind of place that reminds you what Florida used to feel like, and dessert here is more of a simple, classic finish after fresh-caught fish.
Best Bakery-Style Key Lime Dessert · Hometown Desserts
This is where you go when you want something a little richer and more “bakery counter” than restaurant slice. Think thicker texture, slightly sweeter balance, and the kind of dessert you end up taking half of back with you.
Anna Maria (North End)
This is where things feel a little quieter, a little slower, and more residential in the best way. Around Anna Maria, key lime pie shows up in small cafés, waterfront restaurants, and easygoing local spots where the pace matches the setting. It’s less about flash and more about simple, well-done slices you’ll remember after a long beach walk or sunset on the bay.
If you want a deeper dive into local pastry stops, see my Ultimate Guide to Bakeries on Anna Maria Island.
Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery
Classic island stop serving key lime pie in a casual, grab-and-go style—simple, chilled, and easy after a beach walk or bike ride.
House-made key lime pie with a creamy filling, graham cracker crust, whipped cream, and a light cherry syrup drizzle—sweet, simple, and approachable.
Old Florida-style key lime pie with a traditional graham cracker crust and tart, creamy filling. A long-time local favorite known for consistency and classic flavor. It has been voted best Key Lime Pie on Anna Maria Island for nine years in a row.
A creative take featuring a layered key lime tart with lime mousse, cream cheese filling, and decorative white chocolate accents, along with a tropical key lime coconut cake.
House-made key lime pie with a soft filling, graham cracker crust, and signature key lime whip—tangy, smooth, and very “Florida coastal kitchen.”
Key lime pie often finished with a raspberry drizzle and whipped cream—classic island presentation in a true beachfront setting.
Tart, creamy custard-style key lime pie with a toasted coconut graham cracker crust—one of the most well-known sunset dessert spots on the island.
Holmes Beach
Holmes Beach sits right in the middle of the island, which means everything feels easy and accessible. The key lime pie here tends to come from casual restaurants and familiar local favorites—places you’ll likely pass between beach time, bike rides, or lunch stops. It’s straightforward, unfussy, and very much part of an everyday island rhythm.
For a full breakdown of island dining options, see my Anna Maria Island Restaurant Guide.
A chef-driven take on key lime dessert, this coastal tart leans into a cool, creamy texture with a crumbly crust and a lightly sweet citrus finish.
Offers both a classic key lime pie and a coconut key lime cake. The pie stays true to tradition with a tangy filling and smooth texture, while the coconut version adds a tropical twist.
A classic key lime pie that leans into Old Florida simplicity. Made with a traditional graham cracker crust and a smooth, tangy filling with just the right balance of sweet and tart
A true Southern-style key lime pie made fresh in-house using a small-batch family recipe. Balanced between tart and sweet with a simple, homemade feel.
A straightforward, classic key lime pie served in a lively, family-friendly restaurant atmosphere.
Bradenton Beach
This is the livelier stretch of the island, where beach days often roll straight into sunset dinners and evening energy picks up a bit. Key lime pie here is usually found in waterfront restaurants and beachside spots where the view is just as important as what’s on the plate. It’s the kind of place where dessert feels tied to the moment—sunset, salt air, and a table near the water.
For waterfront dining experiences on the island, see my Ultimate Guide to Waterfront Dining on Anna Maria Island.
A well-known local favorite offering a classic key lime pie with a simple, reliable profile and a strong “tourist-meets-local” following.
Beach House Waterfront Restaurant
The key lime pie is creamy and tangy with a light whipped topping, served steps from the Gulf where sunset is part of the experience. It’s less about complexity and more about the full coastal moment—barefoot dining, ocean breeze, and a chilled slice that fits the view perfectly.
Gluten-free friendly key lime pie with a smooth custard texture and balanced tartness, served in an elevated dining setting.
Bridge Tender Inn Dockside & Tiki Bar
Classic Florida-style key lime pie with a tart-sweet filling and graham cracker crust—no-frills, dependable Old Florida style.
Key lime pie made by award-winning Mike’s Pies (Tampa) using Nellie & Joe’s Key West Lime Juice, known for its classic Florida flavor profile.
A laid-back island stop offering both key lime pie and key lime coconut cake—simple, tropical flavors with a relaxed beach-town vibe.
House-made key lime pie with a smooth filling, buttery crust, and light whipped topping—clean, balanced, and modern in feel.
Traditional Florida-style key lime pie made with authentic Nellie & Joe’s Key Lime Juice—simple, tart, and dependable.
Cortez (Just Off the Island)
Cross the bridge into Cortez and everything shifts into something more Old Florida. This is a working fishing village, so the focus is seafood, docks, and no-frills waterfront dining. Key lime pie here isn’t styled or overthought—it’s simple, classic, and often comes after fresh-caught fish in a setting that feels untouched compared to the island just across the water.
For a deeper look at this working waterfront community, see my Ultimate Guide to the Historic Cortez Fishing Village.
An indulgent, presentation-focused bakery featuring key lime pie and layered key lime cake with decorative coastal finishes.
Ultra-simple, old-school key lime pie made with just a few core ingredients—served in a true working fishing village setting.
Homemade key lime pie using Nellie & Joe’s Key Lime Juice, paired with a casual waterfront seafood experience.
Fresh-made daily key lime pie using simple, traditional ingredients with limited production—often available in small daily batches.
Just Beyond Anna Maria Island
If you’re willing to cross the bridge, a few standout spots nearby start to expand the key lime pie experience beyond the island itself. The pace shifts slightly here—still coastal, still relaxed, but with a bit more variety in presentation and setting. It’s not far, but it does feel like a small step into a slightly different version of Florida’s Gulf Coast dessert scene.
Key lime pie with a unique kiwi glaze and whipped cream—slightly more creative and upscale presentation.
A playful island favorite known for its “best west of Key West” reputation. This key lime pie keeps things classic but memorable—bright, tangy filling with a graham cracker crust and that unmistakable Florida flavor.
Not Just Pie: Key Lime Drinks
Key lime pie may be the classic, but around Anna Maria Island you’ll find plenty of other ways that same bright, tangy flavor shows up. From chilled drinks to bakery counter surprises, key lime often gets reimagined in ways that feel a little lighter, a little more playful, and sometimes even more refreshing than the traditional slice.
For more sunset drinks and local specials, see my Discover the Best Happy Hour Spots on Anna Maria Island.
This Key Lime Pie Cocktail was developed in-house and tastes just like key lime pie. It’s made with Siesta Key Toasted Coconut Rum, Stoli Vanilla Vodka, Hard Truth Coconut Rum Cream, fresh lime juice, and coconut cream, then topped with whipped cream and a lime garnish.
Kimmi’s Key Lime Martini is made with Big Storm vanilla vodka, key lime liqueur, key lime juice, and a graham cracker rim.
Final Bite
Key lime pie might have started as a simple solution in the Florida Keys, but here on Anna Maria Island it’s become something of a ritual—best enjoyed after sun, salt, and a long, unhurried beach day.
From barefoot waterfront slices to bakery counters and Old Florida fish houses just over the bridge, every version has its own personality, but they all circle back to the same thing: that bright, tangy reminder that you’re exactly where you’re supposed to be.
On AMI, dessert isn’t an afterthought—it’s part of the experience.
Until next time…
· izzy