Best Shrimp Dishes on Anna Maria Island: My Insider Guide

Updated: November 2026

Fresh Gulf shrimp is as much a part of Anna Maria Island as the white sand and warm water. Cortez, one of the last working fishing villages in Florida, is just across the bridge. This guide covers shrimp dishes in Anna Maria, Holmes Beach, Bradenton Beach, Cortez, and nearby Longboat Key, plus where to buy fresh shrimp to cook yourself. For every other kind of meal on the island, start with Dining on Anna Maria Island: My Insider Guide. Menus and hours change with the season, so call ahead before you go.


Anna Maria

Harry’s Grill

Mother’s Day shrimp paella

Harry’s Grill is a relaxed Anna Maria favorite with string-lit outdoor seating, live music every evening, and a Sunday brunch. The shrimp menu includes peel and eat shrimp, bacon wrapped shrimp, and the Shrimpalooza, a plate of jumbo shrimp cooked the way you like them and served with two sides. The paella pictured here was a Mother’s Day special, so ask about the specials board. If your name is Harry or Harrietta, show proof and enjoy one free draft beer of your choice.

The Porch Restaurant

shrimp and crab dip
  • 9707 Gulf Drive · Anna Maria
  • 941-782-8683

The Porch is a small, cozy spot in the city of Anna Maria. Order the shrimp cocktail or the shrimp and grits, and consider the shrimp and crab dip to start.

Sandbar Seafood and Spirits

Cowboy Shrimp
  • 100 Spring Avenue · Anna Maria
  • 941-778-0444

Sandbar sits right on the beach at the north end of the island and has one of the longest shrimp menus around. The Cowboy Shrimp is the signature starter. Coconut shrimp, chilled Royal Red shrimp, shrimp fettuccini alfredo, and shrimp and grits fill out the list. Read the story behind the Sandbar before your visit.

Slim’s Place

  • 9701 Gulf Drive · Anna Maria
  • 941-567-4056
  • Happy Hour

Slim’s Place is a casual neighborhood bar with a Philadelphia sports theme. Look for the sriracha shrimp lettuce wrap, Thai chili basil citrus shrimp, shrimp taco, and shrimp wrap. For more places to catch the game, see Best Spots to Watch Sports on Anna Maria Island: My Insider Guide.

The Waterfront Restaurant

fried shrimp dinner
  • 111 Bay Boulevard South · Anna Maria
  • 941-778-1515

The Waterfront sits on the water with views toward the Skyway Bridge. The peel and eat shrimp, shrimp and grits, and Gulf fried shrimp are all great choices. For more spots with a view, see Waterfront Dining on Anna Maria Island: My Insider Guide.


Holmes Beach

The Chateau Anna Maria

  • 5325 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
  • 941-238-6264
  • Happy Hour

The Chateau is a more polished option that still feels relaxed. Order the shrimp cocktail or the coconut crunchy shrimp.

The Feast Restaurant

coconut shrimp
  • 5406 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
  • 941-778-5092
  • Happy Hour

The Feast takes shrimp seriously. The coconut shrimp is consistently praised, and the stuffed Gulf shrimp and shrimp and crab alfredo are equally worth ordering.

Freckled Fin Irish Pub

The Freckled Fin is an Irish pub with a coastal twist. The peel and eat shrimp and fried shrimp go well with a cold pint, and the patio has live music most nights.

Hurricane Hanks

beer battered fried shrimp
  • 5346 Gulf Drive · Holmes Beach
  • 941-778-5788

Hurricane Hanks has one of the longest shrimp menus on the island: peel and eat shrimp, Fiery Shrimp, Island Shrimp, shrimp scampi, and a beer battered shrimp platter. If you cannot decide, start with the beer battered shrimp platter.

Isola Bella Italian Eatery

shrimp fra diavolo
  • 5904 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
  • 941-242-5309

Isola Bella gives Gulf shrimp an Italian twist. The gamberi fritte and shrimp fra diavolo are the two to try, and the spicy tomato sauce on the fra diavolo works well with sweet shrimp. For more Italian options, see Italian Restaurants on Anna Maria Island: My Insider Guide.

Kiwi Style Fish and Chips

grilled shrimp and salad
  • 3608 East Bay Drive · Holmes Beach
  • 941-704-5040

Kiwi Style brings a New Zealand approach to Gulf Coast seafood. The shrimp and chips and the shrimp taco are both good, and it is a quick stop when you want something simple.

Rod & Reel

shrimp po’ boy
  • 3246 East Bay Drive · Holmes Beach
  • 941-778-1885

Rod & Reel is a classic island name with a laid-back feel. The shrimp po’ boy, peel and eat shrimp, shrimp skewer, and shrimp dinner are all simple and well done.

The Ugly Grouper

  • 5704 Marina Drive · Holmes Beach
  • 941-896-8033
  • Live Music

The Ugly Grouper covers appetizers, pastas, and full dinners, with live music daily. The menu includes a jumbo shrimp cocktail, coconut shrimp, crab stuffed shrimp, pesto shrimp cavatappi, a fried shrimp dinner, and a coconut shrimp dinner. Take a photo with the Ugly Grouper statue before you leave, and find more photo-worthy stops in Best Instagram Spots on Anna Maria Island: My Insider Guide.


Bradenton Beach

Anna Maria Oyster Bar on the Pier

shrimp ceviche
  • 200 Bridge Street · Bradenton Beach
  • 941-778-2662

Anna Maria Oyster Bar on the Pier is a beloved island institution and the shrimp menu here is as varied as it gets. Start with the shrimp ceviche or peel and eat before moving on to the kaboom shrimp, which is one of those dishes that earns its name. Coconut shrimp rounds out the appetizer lineup, while the shrimp and grits, shrimp dinner, and coconut shrimp dinner give you plenty of options for a full meal. It is the kind of place where you could visit multiple times and order something different every single time.

Bamboo Island Bar

Honolulu
  • 119 Bridge Street · Bradenton Beach
  • 941-803-6416

Bamboo Island Bar brings something truly unique to the shrimp conversation with their Alcapulco and Honolulu, dishes that stand out on an island where most menus lean toward the familiar. If you are the type of traveler who loves discovering something unexpected, this is your spot.

Beach House Waterfront Restaurant

chilled peel and eat Royal Red shrimp
  • 200 Gulf Drive · Bradenton Beach
  • 941-779-2222
  • Happy Hour

Beach House Waterfront Restaurant is one of the most scenic dining experiences on Anna Maria Island and the shrimp menu lives up to the setting. The Chilled Royal Red Shrimp is a standout, delicate, sweet, and best enjoyed slowly with a view of the water. The Coconut Shrimp, Shrimp Po Boy, Creamy Shrimp Linguini, and Fried Shrimp Platter round out a lineup that covers every craving from light and refreshing to rich and indulgent.

Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant

  • 121 Bridge Street · Bradenton Beach
  • 941-896-9737
  • Live Music

Blue Marlin Seafood sources directly from the Cortez fishing fleet, which means the shrimp on your plate was in Gulf waters not long before it reached you. The Florida Cracker Shrimp, Gulf Coast Shrimp Spread, Shrimp Puffs, and Shrimp and Grits are all standouts on a menu that takes boat-to-table seriously. The intimate outdoor Trapyard courtyard setting and live acoustic music on weekends make it one of the most special dining experiences on the island. Reservations are required on nights with live music so plan ahead. For more on Bridge Street dining, see my Ultimate Guide to Bridge Street on Anna Maria Island.

Bridge Street Bistro

  • 111 Gulf Drive · Bradenton Beach
  • 941-782-1122
  • Happy Hour

Bridge Street Bistro brings shrimp into an entirely different setting, a third-floor dining room with panoramic Gulf views. The Prawns with Garlic and Spanish Paprika stand out here, served over yellow rice with vegetables, a Mediterranean-leaning preparation that feels distinct from the fried and grilled shrimp found elsewhere on the island. It is the kind of dish that makes shrimp part of a full dining experience rather than a quick bite, ideal for a date night or a special occasion with a sunset view to match.

Bridge Tender Inn Dockside & Tiki Bar

shrimpcargot
  • 135 Bridge Street · Bradenton Beach
  • 941-778-4849
  • Live Music

Bridge Tender Inn is a classic waterfront experience and the shrimp menu covers all the bases. The Shrimpcargot is the dish that gets people talking, a creative spin on escargot that is uniquely Anna Maria Island. The Buffalo Shrimp, Coconut Shrimp, Shrimp Po Boy, and Shrimp Dinner round out a lineup that works whether you are stopping in for appetizers or settling in for a full meal. Arrive by boat, golf cart, or flip-flops and let the waterfront do the rest. For more waterfront dining, see my Ultimate Guide to Anna Maria Island Restaurants with Boat Parking.

Daiquiri Deck

shrimp po’ boy and shrimp wreck’d

Daiquiri Deck is the spot for anyone who wants their shrimp with a little more flavor experimentation. The Shrimp Wreck’d and Po’ Boy are the standouts, both letting you customize your way to exactly what you want. The hand-breaded shrimp comes tossed in your choice of K-pop Hot Honey, Teriyaki, BBQ, or Buffalo, while the Po’ Boy lets you pick shrimp cooked grilled, blackened, or fried, piled high with shredded lettuce, tomato, and red onion. It is the kind of menu that rewards coming back and trying it a different way every time.

Gulf Drive Cafe & Kokonut Hut

  • 900 Gulf Drive North · Bradenton Beach
  • 941-778-1919
  • Live Music

The Kokonut Hut is one of those quintessential Anna Maria Island spots where everything just clicks. Cold drink in hand, live music in the background, Gulf views straight ahead, and a plate of peel and eat or coconut shrimp that does not disappoint. It is the kind of meal that tastes even better with sand between your toes. For more on the live music scene here, see my Live Music Vibe on Anna Maria Island.

Island Time Bar & Grill

Island Time Bar and Grill keeps things casual and fun with coconut shrimp, peel and eat, and bang bang shrimp tacos that have developed a loyal following among regulars. The open-air patio, daily live music, and laid-back atmosphere make it easy to settle in for the evening.

SALT Bar & Table

SALT Bar and Table offers a chic coastal dining experience and the Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail is a clean, classic choice that lets the quality of the Gulf shrimp speak for itself. Globally inspired dishes, locally sourced ingredients, and an extensive craft cocktail menu make this one of the more sophisticated stops on the island.


Cortez

Cortez Kitchen

  • 4528 119th Street · Cortez
  • 941-900-1506
  • Live Music

Cortez Kitchen sits in the heart of one of the last remaining working fishing villages in Florida and the shrimp menu reflects that heritage in every dish. The Royal Red Shrimp, Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail, Kickin Shrimp Bowl, Shrimp Po Boy, and Shrimp Basket are all prepared with the kind of confidence that comes from being this close to the source. The Kickin Shrimp Bowl earns its name and is one of the more memorable dishes in the area.

Star Fish Company

shrimp and grits
  • 12306 46th Avenue West · Cortez
  • 941-794-1243

Star Fish Company is one of the most authentic dining experiences in the entire area, sitting right on the docks of Cortez with views of the working fishing fleet. The Peel and Eat, Royal Red Shrimp, Coconut Shrimp, Gulf Shrimp Dinner, Shrimp and Grits, and Shrimp Po Boy are all prepared simply and expertly, letting the quality of the Gulf shrimp do the talking. The Royal Red Shrimp earns its spot on the quick picks list and is one of those dishes that makes you understand why people drive out of their way to eat here.

Swordfish Grill

Swordfish Grill brings serious creativity to the Cortez dining scene and the shrimp menu is one of the most exciting in the area. The Firecracker Shrimp, Coconut Shrimp, Peel and Eat, Hand Breaded Fried Shrimp Basket, Firecracker Shrimp Tacos, and Shrimp and Grits give you a range that goes from classic to bold without missing a beat. The Firecracker Shrimp and Firecracker Shrimp Tacos are the dishes that set Swordfish apart and both are genuinely memorable.

Tide Tables Restaurant

  • 12507 Cortez Road West · Cortez
  • 941-567-6206

Tide Tables sits right on the water in Cortez and the Peel and Eat, Shrimp Po Boy, and Shrimp Basket are all served with the kind of straightforward honesty that fits the setting perfectly. It is a no-fuss, all-flavor experience with one of the best waterfront views in the area.


Longboat Key

Mar Vista

shrimp ceviche
  • 760 Broadway Street · Longboat Key
  • 941-383-2391

Mar Vista is one of the most beloved waterfront dining spots in the area and the shrimp menu is a reflection of everything that makes it special. The Tropical Shrimp Ceviche earns its spot on the quick picks list, bright, fresh, and perfectly suited to a warm Gulf Coast afternoon. The Chilled Peel and Eat, Sweet and Spicy Shrimp, and Fried Shrimp Platter round out a lineup that covers every mood and every appetite.

The Lazy Lobster

  • 5350 Gulf of Mexico Drive · Longboat Key
  • 941-383-0440

The Lazy Lobster on Longboat Key is worth the short drive for shrimp lovers. The lineup here is impressive, with a Shrimp Salad Sandwich, Key West Shrimp, Shrimp Scampi, Shrimp Sophia, Coconut Shrimp Salad, Coconut Shrimp, and Big Bang Shrimp all on offer. The Shrimp Sophia and Key West Shrimp are the two that stand out as truly unique and both are worth ordering.

The Shore

  • 800 Broadway Street · Longboat Key
  • 941-259-4600
  • Happy Hour

The Shore on Longboat Key brings a more refined approach to Gulf shrimp with the Deep Water Pink Shrimp Ceviche and Guacamole, a combination that is as creative as it is delicious. It is a sophisticated stop for those who want something a little more elevated on their way through Longboat Key.


Fresh Shrimp to Take Home

Just across the bridge from Anna Maria Island sits Cortez, one of the last remaining working fishing villages in Florida and one of the most special places on the Gulf Coast. Fresh Gulf shrimp does not get any more local than this. For the full story behind this historic community, my The Historic Cortez Fishing Village: My Insider Guide is worth a visit before or after your meal.

Cortez Kitchen

Cortez Kitchen is an excellent option for sourcing fresh local shrimp while you are in the village. Worth calling ahead to check availability as it varies by season and catch.

Star Fish Company

Star Fish Company sells fresh Gulf shrimp directly to the public right from the docks in Cortez. It is as close to the source as you can get and the quality speaks for itself. If you are staying in a vacation rental with a kitchen, picking up fresh shrimp here and cooking it yourself is one of the most authentic things you can do on this trip.

A few tips for buying and cooking fresh Gulf shrimp:

  • Gulf white shrimp is most abundant in the fall but available much of the year
  • Bring a cooler to keep your shrimp fresh on the way back to your rental
  • Fresh Gulf shrimp cooks in just two to three minutes and needs very little seasoning to shine
  • Ask the locals what came in that day as availability changes often and they are always happy to point you in the right direction

Want more real-time tips and honest answers about Anna Maria Island? Join Anna Maria Island Insider, my Facebook group built on one simple rule: real, helpful answers only. Join the group.

Coastal Close

Gulf shrimp is one of those things that tastes different when you are this close to where it came from. Whether you are pulling apart a peel and eat at a tiki bar, digging into a creative shrimp dish at a spot you never would have found without this guide, or cooking up a fresh catch from Cortez in your vacation rental kitchen, Anna Maria Island delivers the real thing every time.

For more on dining around the island, check out my Anna Maria Island Restaurant Guide.

— izzy