A Comprehensive List of Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

Updated: June 2026

Here’s a comprehensive guide to restaurants on Anna Maria Island, curated to help you discover the local spots for every craving from beachfront seafood shacks to hidden gems like tavern-style pizza joints. Whether you’re planning your first visit or a return trip, this guide makes dining on the island easy and delicious.

AMI Beach Hut · 9901 Gulf Drive · 941-281-2124 · general store with hand crafted ice cream, Boars Head sandwiches, snacks, drinks, beach sundries, and convenience items

AM I Coconuts 419 Pine Avenue · 877-AM-I-NUTS · fresh coconuts and coconut drinks

Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery · 941-896-5308 · 9801 Gulf Drive – ice cream and baked goods

Anna Maria General Store · 503 Pine Avenue · 941-779-9200 · island staple for food, drinks, groceries, and beach sundries

Bortell’s Lounge · 10002 Gulf Drive · 941-778-5487 · pub fare, drinks, and sports on TV

Chocolate Emporium · 216C Pine Avenue · 941-345-4020 · candy, chocolates, salt sater taffy, and novelties

Cool Beans AMI · 101 South Bay Boulevard Unit A4 · 941-896-4293 · coffee shop serving coffee, smoothies, breakfast, tea, beer, wine, and AMI merchandise

DBTB Juice Bar & Bakery · 407 Magnolia Avenue · 941-713-4375 · offering breads, pastries, juice, smoothies, coffee, dessert, and catering

Dips Ice Cream · 503 Pine Avenue · 941-778-1706 · ice cream shop

The Donut Experiment · 210 Pine Avenue · 941-896-3172 · donuts you design with choices of icing/toppings and coffee

Ginny and Jane E’s Cafe · 9807 Gulf Drive · 941-778-3170 · eclectic spot serving breakfast, lunch, baked goods, coffee, smoothies, cinnamon rolls, and selling items by local artists

gRub Tropical BBQ · 415 Pine Avenue · 941-900-2874 · casual dining spot serving traditional BBQ with a twist, beer, and wine

Harry’s Grill · 9903 Gulf Drive · 941-567-5999 · casual dining, prime rib, specialty drinks, and live music

Hometown Desserts · 507 Pine Avenue · 941-896-3167 · custom cakes and desserts

Island Ocean Star · 902 South Bay Boulevard · 941-251-6940 · sushi with outdoor dock seating

Mademoiselle Paris French Restaurant & Bakery · 9906 Gulf Drive · 941-226-0708 · French restaurant and bakery serving breakfast, lunch, dinner, pastries, and breads

North Shore Café · 304 Pine Avenue · 941-900-2671 · coffee, teas, acai bowls, smoothies, avocado toasts, and sandwiches

Pizza Social · 308 Pine Avenue · 941-251-4070 · eatery offering handmade pizza, salads, and craft beers

Poppo’s Taqueria · 212C Pine Avenue · 941-254-7941 · Mexican-inspired restaurant offering build yourself burritos and tacos

The Porch · 9707 Gulf Drive · 941-782-8683 · fine dining farm-to-table American plates served in a historic house

Sandbar Seafood & Spirits · 100 Spring Avenue · 941-778-0444 · dine on seafood with your toes in the sand

Slim’s Place · 9701 Gulf Drive · 941-567-4056 · owners from Philadelphia serve lobster mac & cheese, tacos, burgers, Philly cheesesteak, and 11 large TVs

Sushi Ramen · 9801 Gulf Drive Suite 7 · 941-900-2537 · ramen and sushi

Two Scoops · 101 North Bay Boulevard · 941-779-2422 · ice cream shop also serving breakfast and lunch

Waterfront Restaurant · 111 South Bay Boulevard – 941-778-1515 · easygoing spot featuring seafood dishes and craft cocktails

Anna Maria Coffee Shack · 5500 Marina Drive · 941-226-1821 · coffee, breakfast, and light lunch

Anna Maria Island Beach Cafe · 4000 Gulf Drive · 941-778-0784 · beachfront cafe

Anna Maria Island Frozen Yogurt & Acai · 5604B Marina Drive · frozen yogurt and acai bowls

Baskin Robbins · 3302 East Bay Drive · 941-242-0260 · ice cream shop

Blueberries Café and Wine · 5337 Gulf Drive #300 · 786-296-9612 · eclectic mix of acai bowls, empanadas, smoothies, coffee, and beer

The Chateau · 5325 Marina Drive · 941-238-6264 · French and Italian cuisine

Los Chiludos · 3232 East Bay Drive · 941-345-4102 · Mexican outpost providing tacos, burritos, enchiladas

La Crêperie · 3216 East Bay Drive · 941-251-7007 · cafe serving omelets, crepes, coffee and desserts

China 1 · 3236 East Bay Drive · 941-779-2933 · Chinese food

The Doctor’s Garden · 5312 Holmes Boulevard · 941-213-9926 · relaxed elevated dining

The Doctor’s Office · 5312 Holmes Boulevard · 941-213-9926 · craft cocktail bar serving craft cocktails and small plates

Dominos Pizza · 5606 Marina Drive · 941-778-6641 · pizza

Double Deez Chicago Style Hot Dogs · 3009 Gulf Drive · 941-251-5595 · casual eatery offering Italian beef sandwiches, hot dogs, tavern style pizza, and other Chicago eats

Duffys Tavern · 5808 Marina Drive · 941-778-2501 · casual dining serving burgers and beer

Dunkin‘ · 3302 East Bay Drive · 941-242-0260 · coffee shop with baked goods

The Feast Restaurant · 5406 Marina Drive · 941-778-5092 · casual fine dining serving fresh seafood, steaks, and salads

Fifty Three Fifty, The Pourhouse · 5350 Gulf Drive · 941-251-3681 · casual cafe serving coffee, wine, beer, lunch, and dinner

The Freckled Fin · 5337 Gulf Drive · 941-251-3930 · Irish pub with casual dining, live music, and Karaoke

Graze Street AMI · 3218 East Bay Drive · 941-896-6320 · chef-driven modern market offering artisan sandwiches, salads, sweet treats, and charcuterie boards

Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff · 3234 East Bay Drive · 941-779-0690 · ice cream shop

The Hot Dog Guy · 3230 East Bay Drive · hot dog stand

Hurricane Hank’s · 5346 Gulf Drive · 941-778-5788 · casual dining serving fish, burgers, and pasta

Island Fresh Market · 5604 Marina Drive Suite A · 941-567-6130 · boutique grocery store with local seafood and ready-to-eat meals

Isola Bella · 5904 Marina Drive · 941-242-5309 · relaxed Italian eatery

Kiwi Style Fish and Chips Anna Maria Island · 3608 East Bay Drive · 941-704-5040 · local fish coated in crispy batter, burgers, and beer

Minnies Beach Café · 5360 Gulf Drive · 941-778-4140 · cash-only casual nook for breakfast & lunch classics

Paradise Bagels and Café · 3210 East Bay Drive · 941-779-1212 · casual dining serving bagel sandwiches and muffins for breakfast and lunch

Pizzano’s Pizza & Grinderz · 5318 Marina Drive · 941-778-3663 · Detroit style pizza, wings, toasted subs, and sandwiches

Rod N’ Reel Pier · 3246 East Bay Drive · 941-778-1885 · casual seafood

Scott’s Deli · 6000 Marina Drive · 941-778-3000 · sandwiches, wraps, and salads

Skinny’s Bar and Grill · 3901 Gulf Drive · 727-863-4400 · burgers, hotdogs, and homestyle sides

Small Town Creamery · 5404 Marina Drive · 941-213-9107 · ice cream shop

Solos Pizza · 3244 East Bay Drive · 941-778-8118 · Italian food

The Toasted Mango Cafe · 3240 East Bay Drive · 941-213-9948 · traditional breakfast and lunch with a mango twist

Topsail Steamer · 5321 Gulf Drive · 941-254-6060 · seafood steam pots prepared with fresh local seafood

The Ugly Grouper · 5704 Marina Drive · 941-896-8033 · easygoing eatery with live music, seafood and burgers

Vinny’s Italian Kitchen · 5337 Gulf Drive · 941-896-9754 · Italian outfit offering a range of take-out fare

Anna Maria Oyster Bar on the Pier · 200 Bridge Street · 941-778-2662 · casual seafood spot featuring outdoor seating on the water

Back Alley Treasures & Bar · 108 Bridge Street · 224-209-1480 · coffee, light bites, and accessories for sale

Bamboo Island Bar · 119 Bridge Street · 941-803-6416 · Brazilian fusion plates, unique pizzas & mojitos in a bright, lively 2nd-floor hangout

Beach House Waterfront Restaurant · 200 Gulf Drive North · 941-779-2222 · casual dining located on 650 feet off the Gulf

Blue Marlin · 121 Bridge Street · 941-896-9737 · fresh seafood fare with live music

Bridge Street Bistro · 111 Gulf Drive South · 941-782-1122 · upscale casual bistro serving seafood

Bridge Tender Inn · 135 Bridge Street · 941-778-4849 · eatery and bar with dockside seating and occasional live music

Coquina Beach Cafe · 2650 Gulf Drive South · Bradenton Beach · 941-778-4757 · casual beachfront dining and drinks for the whole family

Daquiri Deck · 107 Bridge Street · 941-253-3300 · creative daiquiris, seafood, and live music

Fudge Factory · 117 Bridge Street · Bradenton Beach · 941-281-2501 · offers homemade fudge, ice cream, and chocolate

Gelato-Go Anna Maria Island · 119 Bridge Street Unit 150 · 941-782-8414 · homemade gelato ice cream

Gulf Drive Café · 900 Gulf Drive North · 941-778-1919 · casual indoor-outdoor eatery offering breakfast, lunch, and dinner with live music directly on the beach

Island Time Bar and Grill · 111 Gulf Drive South · 941-782-1122 · casual fare with live music on the beach

The Kokonut Hut · 900 Gulf Drive North · 941-778-1818 · tropical cocktails, casual fare, and sunset views in a breezy tiki bar overlooking the beach

Loyal Order of the Moose · 110 Gulf Dr South · 941-778-4110 · beachfront drinks and casual fare

Omas Pizza and Italian Restaurant · 201 Gulf Drive North · 941-778-0771 · hand-tossed or Sicilian crust pizzas, calzones, and Italian entrees

Pane e Amore Italian Cafe · 119 Bridge Street · 407-492-0121 · Italian pasta dishes, sandwiches, and charcuterie

Salt Bar and Table · 2519 Gulf Drive · 941-896-9897 · seafood and cocktails

Smoquehouse · 1701 Gulf Drive · 941-242-5340 · small menu of made-from-scratch sandwiches, soups, and salads

Wicked Cantina Bradenton Beach · 101 7th Street North · 941-281-2990 · Austin style Tex Mex with live music

---

Cortez Kitchen · 4528 119th Street · 941-900-1506 · seafood casual on the Intracoastal Waterway

Star Fish Company · 12306 46th Avenue West · 941-794-1243 · seafood shack and fish market on the Intracoastal Waterway

Swordfish Grill · 4628 119th Street West · 941-798-2035 · seafood on the Intracoastal Waterway

Tides Table Restaurant · 12507 Cortez Road West · 941-567-6206 · seafood casual on the Intracoastal Waterway

---

Coastal Close

Anna Maria Island is a seriously good place to eat, and this list is just the starting point. For everything in one place, pick up my Anna Maria Island Restaurant Guide on Etsy. Each listing includes location, phone number, hours, happy hour, live music, cuisine, vibe, waterfront, price, and reservations, everything you need to plan the perfect island dining experience.

— izzy